In
a letter J.J. Kirschke wrote to Arthur's daughter, Lori, he
tells of his love and pride for this very special Marine:
Hello
Lori:
Thank
you for your warm note. I am very glad, but not surprised, to
learn that Arthur was such a good husband and father to all
of his children. The Rifle Platoon which I had the privilege
to Command in Vietnam, 3rd Platoon, Hotel Company, 2nd Battalion,
5th Marines, 1st Marine Division, was an outstanding unit in
all respects. Our record in combat proved this, and there are
many indications that we were considered the same way both by
our higher command and by the North Vietnamese Army.
On
the unit's strength aspect, a reading of my book should in large
part prove the foregoing assessment beyond any doubt. In this
Platoon, from the outset and throughout my tour of duty, Arthur
was one of our two or three maneuver Squad Leaders (we were
so short-handed at first that we did not have enough unwounded
Marines with us near the DMZ even to make the three standard
maneuver sub-units). His was almost certainly the strongest
and most reliable of our Squads. Moreover, Corporal Desclos
to me characterized this Platoon in all of its qualities.
As
most unit leaders will tell you, whatever the group, it almost
always takes on special, distinctive, tones, such as depressed,
defeatist, braggadocio, loud, and so forth and so on. Just so,
3rd Platoon, this powerful fighting unit of some 30 tough and
capable Marines, was very much like Arthur; well controlled,
self-contained, healthfully self-confident, reliable, extremely
competent, massively generous, absolutely loyal, loveable, and
quietly and justifiably proud. Every one of these traits your
Father manifested in Spades as a Marine Rifle Platoon Squad
Leader. My instincts tell me, also, that this was Arthur the
entire Man, yes?
For
all of these reasons I loved that Platoon. I'm telling you straight
that I would, without a second's hesitation, have died for them.
And to me Corporal Arthur Desclos represented the heart of 3rd
Platoon. His Squad I would have entrusted with the most difficult
mission with the confidence that Cpl. D., in his quiet way,
would come through in the best fashion possible. What in ways
made him the most remarkable was that he was such a quiet leader.
Revealingly,
the only time, as I mentioned to your Mom, that I EVER heard
him raise his voice was when I surprised him and the other two
maneuver Squad Leaders having a loud argument in an out of the
way gulley near Con Thien (dangerous place!) as to why I had
assigned his Squad the point for two days' combat patrols in
a row. Since you know him as you do, of course, you'll surmise
that he was arguing, "that's that: the Lieutenant has assigned
us point again, and that's the end of the argument!"
The
most popular film about the war thus far is PLATOON, a to me
thoroughly disgusting piece of trash about a fictional US Army
unit. The best way to give you a sense of how Arthur's 3rd Platoon
was would be to say, watch Hollywood's repulsive PLATOON, and
then stand the entire ugly lot of them upside down, and that
would be our 3rd Platoon: where the Army guys are disgusting,
the Marines Arthur and I served with were incredibly good, loveable,
loyal, and absolutely reliable. And Arthur represented well
all of our Platoon's many remarkable qualities, qualities which
have inspired me almost every day of my life for the past 33
plus years.
There's
a lot more I could tell you about your Dad, and all of it is
outstanding! Aside from being a great combat leader, he inspired
his men continually by his example: for instance, I'm almost
certain he hid from me a gunshot wound he had sustained on Operation
Prairie. In addition, he carried the worst case of Jungle Rot
over his entire body(!) that I've ever seen. And never a word
of complaint from him about it. As I recall, once he came down
with immersion foot (skin peeling off from being too often immersed
in water ), and I had to secretly order the medical personnel
to hold him for a few more days inside a tent "in the rear",
since he was so exhausted, and yet he would never have freely
consented to leave his men for even the five to seven days.
On
the most dangerous missions your Father led his men from the
front. I thought the best of Corporal Desclos then, and I continue
to think the best of him now. As I say, I am delighted, but
far from surprised, to hear from you and your Mom that he was
such an outstanding family man. I encourage you to share these
thoughts and recollections with your entire family. I think
we'd all agree that any country would be much better off immediately
if it had a lot more men in it like Arthur Desclos.
I
hope his soul rests in happiness and peace. God bless you all!
Sincerely,
Jim Kirschke
(Arthur's Platoon Commander, 1966-67, and Captain, United
States Marine Corps, Retired)